The Coaching Mixer

Ep 45. Pour the Wine, Skip the Self-Scolding

Written by Erin Aquin | Nov 19, 2026, 9:40:07 PM

What if you don’t have to change your thoughts before you change a situation that isn’t working?

Over wine, Elana and Erin talk about the coaching advice that can keep people stuck, the difference between curiosity and judgment, and why “How’s that working out for you?” makes us want to fall off our chairs.

If you’re weighing a business pivot, a difficult conversation, or a change in your personal life, this episode offers a way to explore your choices without making yourself wrong for wanting something different.

You’ll hear about

  • Why changing a circumstance can reveal beliefs you might not otherwise notice.
  • How coaches can support clients to trust themselves, rather than relying on the coach to have the answers.
  • Why self-scolding isn’t a prerequisite for growth, and what "tough love" might look like instead.
  • What curious questions can uncover when a reaction feels bigger than the moment.

Connect with us:

Elana McKernan is a Master Certified Life and Creativity Coach who specializes in helping perfectionists create more by treating themselves better. Find her on Instagram at https://www.instagram.com/elanamckernan/ and book a consultation at https://www.coachingwithelana.com/book-a-consult.

Erin Aquin is a Master Certified Life Coach and co-author of the #1 bestseller "Superabound: Live the Life the Universe is Dreaming For You." Read the book at https://besuperabound.com/book and book a consultation at https://besuperabound.com/consultation.

Watch here

Listen here:

Listen on Spotify here

Transcript

That would have been a terrible life. Yeah, I was so I was married before my current husband and I didn't know coaching at the time but I know how much how I would have latched on to that idea and used it to beat myself with. Right. And I might have stayed in that relationship much longer and like I don't I can't point to a single thing in my life like a single change that I've made in my life that has had more of a positive impact than getting a divorce. Not that and like he was a he's a great man like he's a lovely person but we were just not compatible and I had so much healing to do on my own that like I could really only do on my own. And yeah, had I had that framework then I think I would have used it against myself to keep myself stagnant for like years longer. I could see that happening.

Are we really saying yes, you should change the circumstance?

I'm just I'm literally as you're saying this I'm just like I'm trying to think of anyone who's gone through something really big where they have done the scary thing of changing their circumstance and then I've then of course they had to deal with their mindset like I'm not saying that there wasn't we're both saying there was a lot of work to do within that and there's there's fallout and you know, it's messy. But like I can't think of anyone I know who who would want to go back to their old incarnation of this lifetime. Yeah. Because sometimes I think it's changing the circumstance it does like if we if we kind of follow that particular tool, changing the circumstance prompts different thoughts. Mhm. And if that's what we're trying to do, if we're trying to think better thoughts, you could give yourself a whole new circumstance, which would might be a lot easier to not fall into like old patterns and like old mindset stuff. Mhm. Yeah. I definitely think that's an element of it. So, I I Here's what I think about this. I think it's about your relationship with yourself. [snorts] All right. Underneath all of it. Like that's what I think it all all always comes back to, but I think in terms of like changing your circumstance, not changing your circumstance, I think what a lot of that style of coaching doesn't acknowledge is the thoughts that are driving a person to stay that are like humming quietly in the background and often are not surfaced in coaching. Like I think for me when I was in that marriage, a lot of the thoughts that were driving me to stay were like, I'm never going to find someone who loves me like he does. I'm never going to find I know. My poor little old lady. I know. She was like in her 20s and she was so deeply traumatized. Um but like there were a lot of yeah, like I I don't like I I'm going to be lonely for the rest of my life. Like I'll never find another companion. This is my fault, so like I should be able to make this work. Stuff like that. Mhm. That I think this idea of not changing your circumstance actually would have enabled me to avoid looking at that stuff for longer, but in experiencing the like circumstance change, it surfaced and I was like I had to prove to myself like well, obviously there are other people out there and obviously I'm like okay and I have a uh support network that I didn't realize I had. So like I don't know that activity itself didn't necessarily change my thoughts, but I was like forced to be scrappy and try new things and confront some of my fears and that helped me shift my relationship to myself so that I was like oh actually like I'm I'm not bad. Like I'm pretty cool. Yeah, I'm awesome. [laughter] A lot of like connections that a person can have out there. There are a lot of different interesting people to meet. So I think I think that might be it. Like I do know some people in my family and my extended family who are kind of like trying to outrun themselves and that is a tragic thing in its own right and I probably would not have the same take for people who are like who clearly avoiding looking at themselves and like using external uh circumstance changes in order to do that. But I think that's because they're like the underlying relationship to themselves is like I can't sit still. I don't want to look at like there's a lot of stuff that I don't want to look at. I can't handle it if I have to look at that. So like yeah, I think it's much more about that dynamic you have with yourself than with change your circumstance or not.

Make it so [laughter] mind blowing. It's It's It's true and I mean the wild thing as as you're saying that I'm just like and no one who's a coach like an actual an actual thoughtful coach who knows how to process emotions, who's like doing this deep introspection work falls into that category. I just can't think of a single coach who's like trying to outrun themselves by changing circumstances and would Yeah. Like I'm sure some of our clients do. I'm I I work with entrepreneurs. Sometimes that's the case. But I feel like those people tend to not be able to hear that. They tend to be like, "No, no, it's the world. I have to like I don't even think this teaching's necessarily of like work it out within the circumstances you're in. I don't even think that teaching would be seen by somebody who's in that outrunning themself kind of cycle. Yeah. And I I think what's tragic is like the rest of us have been like, "Oh, I'm so I'm so inside like introspective. Let me sit with this horrible situation I'm in and think that my job is to change my thoughts about it before I allow myself the option of changing the circumstance." Mhm. And funny enough, I think very few of that person that you mentioned who are like that person who's like trying to outrun themselves, very few of them are going to seek out coaching and they certainly are not going to seek out coaching with No. us. [laughter] No, they're going to be like, "I don't like what she said about not changing the circumstances about Right. Because we're going to be like, "Hey, well, what you feeling? What's going on for you? Why do you want that thing?" Like not even that it's a bad thing, but it like let's just explore. Well, do you like your reasons for it? Like you can't really hide in a room with those types of questions. So, I don't think they're going to be putting themselves in those rooms very often. It's so interesting. I I love that we've like come here because it's like it is an important teaching and we can see a lot of examples of people in the world who try to change their circumstances to feel better. And what we're saying is most of them are not seeking out coaches to resolve that. They're buying Lamborghinis or marrying their fifth seventh Yeah. person or moving here and moving there. Like they're not probably doing it because that's like not on their radar that there's another way. Mhm. When it comes onto their radar that there might be another way, I think they've already understood something and they probably can't get there by somebody saying stop trying to change your Like I don't think anyone's going to convince them otherwise until they come Like this is where what I really loved about what you said earlier is like people have to be free to kind of come to these things on their own. Mhm. Because we can teach this stuff all day, but if it's not like landing with a potential client, I mean, that's not good for our businesses, but it's also like not helping anyone and then we're turning these tools on ourselves. Mhm. Yeah. Yeah. And I think the work as coaches, well, I don't know. I want I was going to say that so confidently. I'm like, wait, do I believe that? I wonder is the I I want to propose perhaps the the work as coaches is kind of the same whether they change their circumstance or not. Because like what we're really doing is we're helping them connect to themselves and like build a better relationship, like more loving, more gentle relationship with themselves. So like you can do that in any context. So does it really matter if they're trying to change their circumstance or not to feel better? Yeah. It's I think what's humbling too is like we actually have no idea. Like I never question anything when they're like, I'm leaving my partner or I'm pivoting my business or I'm closing my thing or I'm doing this. I'm just like if they sound clear and they share why that feels like the right direction to move in, I never say, wait, let's stop. Let me make sure that this sounds really serious, sounds like a big deal. I just go with it as the truth. Mhm. And unless something comes up where they're like I know if it's a struggle if they're tense about it or if there's processing that we need to do, then we can open that up. But I just I've really stopped saying, "Well, this is a really big deal and are you totally sure?" And let's go through like they're going to have a thousand other people ask them those questions. Yeah. I have decided I'm going to be the person that just believes what they're bringing. And helps them sort through whatever's on their mind about that. Mhm. Like "How am I going to have this conversation? How am I going to let my clients know? How am I going to" Like whatever it is. [clears throat]

It's very liberating for people. From what From what I've seen with people I've gone through this with, it's like it feels nice to not have

friction or resistance. And if there's friction or resistance within them, it comes up because I don't have any friction or resistance. And I'm just like, "Oh." I'm like, "Okay, well, you sound really clear." And they're like, "Wait, wait, wait, but do you understand what I'm saying?" And I'm just like tell I guess I don't. Like it sounds like there's more [laughter] here. Yeah. [clears throat]

It's a It's a really um It's a really funny thing, like

I wonder why we take those circumstance changes as like such a big

deal. Mhm. Because usually when people bring that stuff like they've thought about it, they understand it's going to be hard. Every circumstance change is like there's work. Yeah, nobody like changes a job or a partner or like gets a divorce without Well, I mean, maybe there are some people, but most people don't do that without having put some thought into it and like understood some of the gravity of that decision. And if they know that it's going to be work and it still feels like a relief, Mhm. that's when you're like, well, sounds like you know something about yourself. Mhm. Sounds like you know something about what you want. Yeah. And I just and maybe I'm wrong maybe other people would disagree with me, but like I feel like it would be really insulting for me as their coach to be like, wait, let's back like you need to explain this all to me. Mhm.

You need to tell me why. You need to tell me what your reasons are and I'm going to like judge whether I like your reasons that you're telling me like Yeah.

I would probably not like that coach.

I feel like they're hot. I don't know if I don't I can't think of like a deep coaching relationship I've had with that energy, but like I hate that energy that's like okay, it's like that how's that working out for you kind of energy. I hate that so much. [laughter] [gasps] Erin is melting onto the floor for the onto the floor.

I hate that energy so much. It's so lazy. It's such a lazy question cuz it's not even a question. It's a judgment that's couched as a question.

And the people the thing that I hate the most about it is like how many clients I see then like sort of internalizing that they did something wrong. They're like, oh yeah, like it's not I'm doing I'm thinking the wrong thoughts here. I hate that. Yeah. Yeah. For coaches, I think it's really good to remember that even if you have a personal judgment, which we're all allowed to have as humans, if you think, you know, you can have a personal judgment about someone and their life and all of the things. But, the second

you start to like put some kind of morality or personal spin on what you think someone else should do. My My honest opinion about this is you better be like an enlightened being [clears throat] if you're going to say some [ __ ] like that. Mhm. And I just don't think an enlightened being would say that. They wouldn't. They [laughter] wouldn't. They wouldn't. How's that working out for you? Like I'm sure the Buddha's not like, "How's that working out for you?" [laughter] Yeah, no. That's not a be like in that person's life. I mean, that wouldn't be a coaching relationship, but like

someone's trusting you with something that they're feeling vulnerable about. They maybe have not said it to another person. They're sharing their like deep, dark, scary thoughts. And you're going to have such a flippant reaction? Yeah. It's Yeah.

If you need a second because you're having a personal judgment, just take a second. Mhm. Just say or say like, "Wow, that's That sounds like a big thing." Mhm. [clears throat] That's okay. Like you can be a human, but like in that space "How's that working out for you?" Oh my god. I can't. Yeah. I know. I know. Thank you for being on the same page on that. on the floor. that so much. Yeah. Can we talk for a second about the difference between that and like sharing what you see? Cuz I do have some I do think sometimes not as judgment, but like if I notice a client is maybe drawing a very extreme interpretation from something that like from my point of view is like kind of minor actually. Um I I like how do you do you have those experiences and how do you handle them cuz I do think there's value in like voicing observations. Not in a judgmental place but in a place of like huh like this is interesting that you're having this reaction and I'm having this reaction like can we investigate that a little bit? Yeah, I mean I think what you just said is very brilliant. That's like a great way I also I kind of do it that I'm just like okay wait. I'm like I'm not following. Mhm. [clears throat] They said this and then you felt like you were going to like burn the building down. I'm just like tell me what like I I call them thought leaves. I'm just like they went from here over a chasm into like some extreme place. Like I'm like I'm not making the leap with you. Like tell me just like walk me through what you made that mean or like

they they did this thing that just like seemed like a little annoying or benign in some ways but then you felt so much rage. Like I I think about my own experiences of that and I will sometimes I will say I will do the the horrible thing of giving an experience share to my [gasps] I know. I know. [laughter] I'm so sorry to tell you. I will say something often like I'm trying to understand like sometimes when someone does this I might feel disrespected and that's like my that's like the it's the thing it's like the the end of the dynamite stick for me. If somebody if I feel disrespected it's like oh somebody lit that little fuse and it's slowly going kaboom. That's my response to it and I'm just like what fuse was lit for you because I like maybe it's just not mine. Yeah. And they're like, "Oh, well, it was incompetent." And they were like, you know, or they were like not caring about this thing that I care so deeply about. I'm like, "Okay." So, you took this thing and you you made it mean this. How do we go back and like verify whether that's what it was? Was it callousness? Was it carelessness? What Did they even know that you felt this way? Like, we can kind of do an investigation. But I never am like, "Well, that was stupid. Why did you have feel that? That's a dumb way to feel." [laughter] Because I'm like, no, if somebody if I feel disrespected, everybody take cover. Yeah. I love that because I think what's most needed in those moments is like space for it to breathe and to like be voiced. And that often will diffuse a lot of the intensity of it for clients, but even if it doesn't, then like as coaches, we have much more information about our clients and we can support them. I think I think that helped me identify what feels so icky about the like how's that working out for you versus the like open curiosity. Which is like the the how's that working out for you is like an energy it's like a paternalistic energy. It's like, "I know better than you." "And I'm casting judgment on you. And like I'm the the like big daddy. Big daddy is going to come in and and like help you whip your thoughts into shape." Versus like, "Oh, help me understand. Like, I'm on your side. I'm not above you. I'm on your side. Like, help me understand what is happening here because I'm having trouble connecting the dots." Yeah. Because nobody's their big daddy spanking them. Unless that's like your thing. Maybe you like that, but like that's not what your coach is for. You can even I mean some people do want those kinds of coaches. That's not my style of coaching at all. And I don't like that style of coaching just to be fully transparent. Like that's not my jam. Me neither. I don't think it's effective because then you actually don't find out what the mechanism was and what the trigger was and what the thought leaf was. You just feel diminished and then you're like, "Oh, this person's not safe to actually share my legitimately horribly feel horrible feelings." And like they just gave me a little spank that I didn't ask for. Or that I did ask for. Or yeah. [laughter]

If you like it, that's fine, but [laughter] but in the coaching relationship I I agree with you. I think it's lazy and I think that it puts a stop to like getting any deeper. It just like It makes It makes the coaching session like school. Yeah. It's like I need to have the correct answer and then say, "You're right. My thought was terrible. I'm a bad person. I will work on my thoughts and I will never tell you anything real about me ever again." Mhm. Yeah. It It takes away all safety, I think. I agree. And now that I'm at the bottom of my drink, I will even go a step further and say I think it not only does it remove safety, I think it creates dependency, which I think is like actually consciously or unconsciously intentional for some styles of coaching and some coaches. And I find it very icky and like I do not like it, but I do think that there are some some coaching dynamics where that actually like the coaches do fancy themselves like above their clients and view their role as being one of like schooling their clients and like creating accountability for their clients in a way that's like big daddy coming in with billiard stick. Um, and some clients do want that. Um, I'm not going to judge that impulse cuz like I think I I kind of understand why that would come in it, but like I think the coaches do um, yeah. I think coaches should not participate in that. I don't like that. Yeah. Um, and I'll say like I have I have had clients for years who came in saying, "I need you to tell me the truth and give me the tough love and da da da da da." And I'm like, "When I'm aware that that's a dynamic that they're looking for, I this could be totally wrong, but I say I like it just it's a good reminder to myself that I'm kind of like my little an agenda. Oh, no. My agenda in the corner is to show them that actually they can grow without self-scolding. And then I say, "Okay, are you ready for the tough love? The tough love is I think the way you're feeling makes total sense. And I think you really want me to tell you that it's you should change your thinking about it, but I think the hard part here is going to be having the conversation with the person like defining what is okay with you and what is not. And like I think that's the hard part. And people want to hear like, "Oh, it was me and I'm bad." They don't want to do the hard vulnerable thing. Like the tough love is I think you might have to be vulnerable with this other Oof. person, which is so much harder than me saying, "Well, how is that thought working out for you?" Yeah. Just go do your What are they called? Um, self-lashings or your penance or whatever. Yeah. [laughter] And you can do if it's what you want to do, but like I hope that you get some pleasure from it, whatever is going on there. [laughter] No judgment. People can have their things, but like I I to your point, I think that when coaches play into that dynamic, it's an icky like dependency-building tactic that um it's I think it's bad business. I think it's lazy business. I'm like if you can't create clients that actually want to be in your presence because you genuinely help them and they feel better because of the work that you've done together and their lives are transformed and they really love who they are and they love their life. Like that's how I want I want my clients to feel that way about me. I don't want them to be like if I leave her, then I'm going to have to figure out, you know, how to stay in this horrible relationship or this horrible business that I hate and I'm not going to have anyone to crack the whip on me. I don't know. I don't That's not I'm not going to do that. [laughter] We need to get me a lot more money for that. I not And like maybe a different context or something like That's a different business that I That's a different my 60s I'll open a new business, but not now. I like I love that. I love helping people like have a better relationship with themselves and I know Yeah. Me too. I mean, transparently that is my agenda as well. Like I want [clears throat] my clients to build a stronger relationship with themselves. Like more trusting, more loving, kinder. So like the idea of asserting myself as somehow like more knowledgeable or above them Yeah. is like antithetical to that. Yeah. We already have a world that's trying to do that. Oh my god. let's like if we want to actually change the world as coaches, I think that that what you just said is the path forward for all of our us and all of our clients. Yeah. And I also do want to say like I I most people who are listening to this are probably not going to fall into that category and also like there are I want to acknowledge there are pressures especially for new coaches that I had to work through to like be the expert. Like that dynamic it doesn't appear out of nowhere and it's not always like a nefarious thing. I'm just like And I do think like as you grow your own confidence like my confidence skyrocketed when I like stopped making myself the center [laughter] of my clients' lives in my mind when I was like oh actually I'm like just a coach like I'm not making their decisions for them. I don't want to be making their decisions for them. I don't need to be. I don't need to know more than them. Like they have everything they need and I'm just here to like help them access that. Um but that I guess I was just to say like if this is something you're like I don't know do I do this? I would like just for one thing you're not like a terrible person if you notice some impulses toward this. Like I don't know about you Erin but like I do remember there were coaching sessions where I'm like I'm going to say the wrong thing which does kind of position me above my clients a little bit that like I have the power to either make or break them in a way and for me it was just a process of being like my values around coaching don't align with that and I don't need to like I'm not that important honestly. Yeah. Um Oh my god I once got so much feedback on my coaching that was like you talked for 20 minutes. That was not a coaching session. That was a class. I'm like Oh. Start a podcast. If you are like us and you want to talk about these things start a podcast. Have a podcast. Yeah. We can talk all the time. We'll talk in your ear but the coaching session is like it's that person's like sacred space and I'm always trying to figure out ways to

support people like the way that they need to and I think that comes and it comes and she like to your point it's not nefarious if you're doing it unconsciously because that's maybe how you learned too. A lot of a lot of coaches like teach in this way where that like that's how you do it. You want to keep your clients make sure they track they say what their takeaway was and they start the session telling you what the homework that they did like there is a movement towards that but if you are feeling icky about it I think you might be at a point in your coaching that you could let that go perhaps [clears throat] and just figure out how to be more present and give people what whatever they need. It's a lot easier and a lot more fun in my opinion. Way more fun. I love that we got here from being tired and like [laughter] not knowing how to take time off of work. To to big daddy coaches. To big daddy cracking the whip. Amazing. Oh there'll be some good clips for this one everybody. Oh I'm sure. At least the latter half. I don't know about the first half but the latter half for sure. [laughter] Who knew our wine Who knew? Yeah. More wine episodes is the moral of that story. Before we say goodbye can you tell people how they can find you a a decidedly not big daddy coach? Alaina.notbigdaddy.com. [laughter] Coachingwithalaina.com.

Yes. I also I think we're going to have to do an episode about this at some point but I am like I've finally feeling some movement around creating some new things in my business. So I'm just going to put that plant that little teaser here. I haven't really like done much with it but I'm excited about talking more about creating new things and giving yourself the space to do that. Okay, teaser. I don't even know what we're going to talk about. [clears throat] I'm so excited. I don't either. All right, where can people find you? Um, besuperbound.com/coachingmixer, where all the show notes will be. You can click around to find where I am. Um, and I promised you I would let you know by the time this episode comes out the Superbound Oracle will be totally available. I am working on having it be in different stores in different locations. You can also order it from me, um, but that will be over at uh, superbound.besuperbound.com/oraclejourney,

and all the details are there. I'm like falling off of my chair but in excitement. Not in misery, like I was. Not in misery or disgust, in enthusiasm. Yeah, and you were a big part of like inspiring me to do that. Like all of our talking about being creative and being an artist, and you know, I told you my little wild idea like in the first couple of episodes, and now yeah, the cards are being printed as we speak, and they will be available by the time this comes out. Which is so cool, and also such a good reminder that like if you have an idea, you can just do do it. Do it. [laughter] Yeah. A little bit at a time, and then maybe it'll you'll be announcing it on your own podcast. [laughter] Yeah. Yay! Yay. All right. Thanks for having me, everyone.